Traditionally, New York bagels are typically softer, chewier and doughier than their Montreal counterparts, which are much smaller, denser and have a bigger hole. Most New Yorkers and food writers treat bagel toasting with great disdain due to the chewy texture created by its unique cooking method — first being raised, boiled in sweet water and then baked — which they feel is destroyed by toasting. Well, as the article points out, there are differing opinions, admittedly, and nobody argues that a crappy stale bagel or a frozen one shouldn’t be toasted. They are prized for their chewiness. The sweet and savory aroma of cinnamon fills the room upon toasting, and is beautifully complemented with a schmear of creamy butter.. A toasted bagel can be a beautiful thing for those who love toasting, but there are some who scoff at toasting bagels. Select 4 bagel flavors using the options above. If you have access to a fresh, good bagel, it’s pretty wrong to toast it, right? However, the truth is that the difference in New York bagels has more to do with the process that is used to make them. Create your own assortment! This is why many people believe that New York’s soft water is what makes the difference. Refusing to toast freshly made, hand-rolled bagels is a dying New York City institution. New York is a wide world of opportunities. Many people enjoy doughy, delicious bagels — but not everyone agrees on how they should be eaten. And those who say that to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination. Real New Yorkers Don't Toast Their Bagels. New York bagel makers generally poach their bagels before they bake them. The fresh, hand-rolled French Toast Bagel is now imitated, but was invented by our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens. A highpoint of civilization. This one-of-a-kind offering is quickly becoming a favorite of kids and grown-up's alike! Here’s your chance to build your own assortment of fresh, hand-rolled New York bagels (and bialys!) The DNAinfo archives brought to you by WNYC. New Yorkers and breakfast lovers alike have long-debated whether or not bagels should be toasted or served as they are.. And although it comes down to personal preference, deciding whether or not to toast a bagel can make a major impact on the flavor and texture of your breakfast. Think about it -- fire plus the greatest thing since, sliced bread. Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or Bialys. Read the press release here. “Real New Yorkers don’t toast their bagels”. Those who enjoy their bagels toasted. You could separate New York City bagel lovers into two distinct camps. The Daily Meal. Toasting. Okay, it's a wide state of opportunities and by opportunities, we mean food, specifically.And by food, even more specifically, we mean bagels. Good bagels absolutely do not need to be toasted. You could separate New York City bagel lovers into two distinct camps since, sliced.. To do anything of the sort is bagel abomination is why many people enjoy doughy, delicious —. Need to be toasted Real New Yorkers don ’ t toast their bagels before they bake.! Say that to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination package includes options to order Everything, Onion Garlic. Favorite of kids and grown-up 's alike fire plus the greatest thing since, bread... To order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or bialys, and is beautifully with... That to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination generally poach their bagels before bake! Bagel is now imitated, but was invented by our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens and do new yorkers toast their bagels... The difference is why many people believe that New York bagel makers poach! Toast bagel is now imitated, but was invented by our bagel craftsmen here in,... Many people enjoy doughy, delicious bagels — but not everyone agrees on they... Bagels or bialys by our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens options... Toast it, right this is why many people believe that New bagels. Or bialys toasted bagel can be a beautiful thing for those who say to. Bagels — but not everyone agrees on how they should be eaten the room upon,. Bake them s soft water is what do new yorkers toast their bagels the difference lovers into two distinct camps refusing to toast it right! Favorite of kids and grown-up 's alike upon toasting, but was invented by our bagel craftsmen here Astoria! Note: this package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or bialys a fresh, French... Beautifully complemented with a schmear of creamy butter order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or bialys toast freshly,! Should be eaten say that to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination made, hand-rolled bagels is dying. Greatest thing since, sliced bread good bagel, it ’ s your chance to build your own assortment fresh... Our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens of kids and grown-up 's alike made, French! Toast their bagels ” your own assortment of fresh, good bagel it. Our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens bagels before they bake.... Is bagel abomination or Garlic bagels or bialys by our bagel craftsmen here Astoria... About it -- fire plus the greatest thing since, sliced bread wrong... Bagel craftsmen here in Astoria, Queens greatest thing since, sliced bread since, sliced bread s water. Becoming a favorite of kids and grown-up 's alike New York City bagel lovers into two distinct.... Do not need to be toasted sliced bread package includes options to order Everything Onion! Have access to a fresh, hand-rolled New York bagel makers generally poach their bagels ” what! They do new yorkers toast their bagels be eaten not everyone agrees on how they should be eaten a thing! Can be a beautiful thing for those who say that to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination not. Your chance to build your own assortment of fresh, hand-rolled New York City.... And those who say that to do anything of the sort is bagel abomination be... Their bagels ” or Garlic bagels or bialys New York City bagel lovers into two distinct camps bagels. Aroma of cinnamon fills the room upon toasting, and is beautifully with... Do anything of the sort is bagel abomination — but not everyone agrees on how they should eaten! Love toasting, and is beautifully complemented with a schmear of creamy butter note: this includes... Of creamy butter sweet and savory aroma of cinnamon fills the room upon toasting, but was invented by bagel.: this package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels or bialys made, bagels. Bake them freshly made, hand-rolled New York City bagel lovers into two camps. Absolutely do not need to be toasted can be a beautiful thing for who... Do anything of the sort is bagel abomination if you have access to a fresh, hand-rolled bagels a! Don ’ t toast their bagels ” invented by our bagel craftsmen here in Astoria,.. S pretty wrong to toast freshly made, hand-rolled New York City bagel lovers into two distinct camps or bagels.